​Why Did They "Give Him Back"

Behind The Baby Cyrus Story ☆ The Ammon Aspect

​Of course the main reason is Ammon Bundy —but why?

​It wasn't just that he organized with others and generated overwhelming public support, forcing authorities into the decision to return the baby to his parents.

What was the real reason behind it?

​After taking the baby at St. Luke's, a judge later placed him under a 45-day custody hold, only for the agencies involved to abruptly reverse course and return Cyrus to his parents.

However, they insisted the mom and dad sign a highly intrusive safety plan containing procedures detrimental to the baby's health.

Why?

​As noted by counsel for St. Luke’s, the objective extended beyond stopping Ammon as an individual (and I suppose, his run for governor); it was about preventing any future resistance of this nature from occurring.

Why Did They Single Out Ammon, Diego, and the People's Rights Network?

Ammon had previously secured major legal victories—acquitted in Oregon for the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge Occupation, and seeing charges dismissed with prejudice in Nevada for the fed-led standoff on the Bundy Ranch.

Through those efforts, he drew supporters by the thousands to stand against government overreach. That same ability to mobilize showed up at St. Luke's, where hundreds of people got involved.

Having beaten federal prosecutors in Oregon and Nevada—where the government faced scrutiny for withholding information, including Giglio and Brady violations—the strategy shifted in Idaho.

​When the battle moved to Idaho, the objective became shutting down the movement by any means necessary, using the civil legal system to achieve what criminal prosecution could not.

​Ultimately, the aftermath of the Baby Cyrus situation marked a turning point in how institutions responded to Ammon's brand of direct-action activism.

Where federal prosecutors had failed in the criminal courts of Oregon and Nevada, a private healthcare system stepped into the civil arena—armed not with criminal statutes, but with defamation claims.

For years, Ammon had been a thorn in the side of the powers that be, making himself a target because of what he stood up for and his willingness to buck the system. That deep-seated hostility toward his resistance was at the root of the push to finally take him down.

​Before the contempt trial, Ammon had already refused to participate in the original defamation lawsuit. He and his wife, Lisa, both stated they would not try to defend themselves against a corporation backed by multi-million-dollar lawyers, figuring it was better to simply take the $50,000 default judgment hit rather than fight it in court.

​That refusal to participate eventually led to the contempt proceedings. On November 13, 2023, Judge Nancy Baskin said she would issue a new arrest warrant for Ammon, setting bond at $250,000 after he failed to appear for the first day of his contempt trial in Ada County.

An earlier warrant had carried a $10,000 bond, and Ammon had emailed the parties the day before stating he would not be in the courtroom that day—or any other day.

Here's the part I can't shake. The baby was home before St. Luke's ever filed. The protests came first, then Cyrus went back to his parents in mid-March, and on May 11, 2022, the hospital sued Ammon, Diego Rodriguez, and the People's Rights Network.

By then Cyrus was no longer the story. Ammon was. In my opinion, the timing looks like a case that wanted the Baby Cyrus part of it out of the way so it could focus solely on Ammon.

​The contempt charge followed a July civil trial in which a jury found Ammon and Diego Rodriguez liable for defamation over the Baby Cyrus case, ordering them to pay $52.5 million to St. Luke's and the other plaintiffs.

According to the Idaho Dispatch, they were also ordered to remove their online posts; Ammon was charged with contempt when the posts stayed up. That night, Ammon said, "I don't regret any of it."

​By shifting the battleground to financial liability and court-ordered injunctions, the Idaho litigation demonstrated that while street-level mobilization could pressure local agencies in the short term, sustained civil litigation could dismantle an activist network's momentum far more decisively than a criminal trial ever had.

This accompanying photograph captures a crucial moment from December 2017—when Ammon walked out of the federal courthouse in Las Vegas.

This reunion came prior to the mistrial and the eventual dismissal with prejudice that secured his full legal victory in Nevada. It was a victory not just in the courtroom, but in the real world: the day they finally gave him back to his children.

GIVE HIM BACK - the entire full film - is now playing and being voted on!!! Angel is also having a black friday sale, so if you don't have it, now is the time!

If you want to watch/vote from your computer, sign in, and then use this link, and you can skip to our film:

https://www.angel.com/vote/torch-full-length

From the phone or TV, you need to login, go to GUILD, Adults, Full Films, and then skip until you see GIVE HIM BACK

We need every vote it can get right now as it comes down to the wire!!!

​Angel Studios gave me this link to offer one person a free one-month membership.

​https://www.angel.com/guild/share/B26IWUG49AG958H

I'm putting it here for whoever gets here first—first come, first serve!

— Vincent Easley II https://reallibertymedia.com/author/https-reallibertymedia-com-author-vine

Get the latest episodes directly in your inbox